Author’s overall rating: 9.5/10; The Test. Excellent shirt. They only do 1 merino wool shirt (and a long sleeve version). Smartwool vs. Icebreaker. I like supporting companies that … They and Icebreaker are merino blends with synthetics though, and I've had issues with certain synthetics holding onto odor. Which one will make you feel like this guy right here: By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. Icebreakers are super comfortable, and they look great, but they don't last. I am not able to conclude that Icebreaker is more breathable than Smartwool because I find Smartwool and Icebreaker to be identical from a performance standpoint. Woolly v neck in black. Now I need another baselayer, and I SHOULD just get another Smartwool NTS 250. If you get a hole somewhere that doesn't bother you, it won't suddenly lead to the tee coming apart when you least expect. Got one for the wife too. But being human, this seem boring, and I'm wondering if there is … The absol6 DISRESPECT for leaving out darn tough.. For 1/2 the price I'd go with Icebreaker. Therefore, it is perfect for winter hiking and other activities in cold weather. What's your experience with them and recommendation? Also if you won't be washing clothes\showering regularly wool would have the advantage there as it won't stink as bad. I like Icebreaker because the fit/cut is nice, and because they are GREAT about returns/warrantee stuff, but they are also very expensive. Which one do you prefer for warmer weather? The Smartwool tee with the nylon core and the Icebreaker with the TENCEL seem very intriguing. Comfortable, breathable, odor resistant. I wear this a lot and it is comfortable. But for real, smart wool may have other products, but darn tough just has it down.. their socks are so much more dense. Our sweaters and hoodies are made from sustainably sourced merino wool and are designed to last the distance. XXL and barely big enough but fits very well. As mentioned above I wore the Smartwool base layers for an entire week during a backcountry ski trip. Got it in XL tall and love it. The wool underwear sold by Smartwool and Icebreaker is for high exertion outdoor sports such as backpacking and cross country skiing. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker vs. Wooly seems to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but which one? Here are some impressions that should help you out! Probably varies from production lot to lot more then brand to brand, anything under 200gsm is going to have a pretty short life no matter the name on it. I definitely don't have to worry about a tall size. All the ladies in the office love Kari Traa’s baselayers for their fun patterns, bright colors, and, well, spunk. I prefer the Woolly ones as they're softer & comfier. The Mission Statement: http://www.reddit.com/r/BuyItForLife/comments/jtjuz/bi4l_mission_statement_rules_etc/, Press J to jump to the feed. Ik twijfel tussen het aanschaffen van Smartwool mid skisokken of Icebreaker mid skisokken (beide dames, merinowol resp. I have some pendleton mills Sir Pendletons and Board Shirts that fit great. I'm looking to pick up some wool casual wear to make this year's warm weather travel a little more efficient, picking up a wool t-shirt and polo. The fabric is gorgeous, and their real claim to fame is in finding the 'perfect fit'. I've seen some people ask about each of these clothing brands individually, but have yet to see a discussion on a comparison across brands of one specific item. I find Smartwool to be more durable and comfortable. A Woolly v neck & henley as a mid layer retains a good amount of warmth. Smartwool Hunt Extra Heavy OTC Socks. The Smartwool NTS Mid 250 Crew base layer differs from the Icebreaker Oasis Long Sleeve Crewe in density of the fabric – it is made of a thicker fabric. Smartwool socks and accessories have served me well for outdoor sport use, so I lean that way on one hand because it's a known quality to me. Recommendation/Help. Neither are hurting for cash and both want to sell. To answer your question, I would choose Woolly out of the 3 for a tshirt and polo if you don't need a tall size. Blended merino (poly or nylon) should last a good bit longer, especially at the lower weights. Considering the fact that they are about half the price of the others listed above I was skeptical. Also, for anyone interested, I bought a woolly shirt & undies. Wash them by hand only to prolong their life, but expect small holes relatively soon. You should check out Son of A Tailor. For our Icebreaker vs Smartwool comparison, we've chosen the Icebreaker Tech Lite Short Sleeve Crewe against the Smartwool Merino 150 Short Sleeve. granted, its still so thin i dont see it lasting much longer. I’ve alternated between Icebreaker and Smartwool over the years. Worth the high price tag. However the holes don't seem to grow, in my experience. **Reminder:** Please use the search function before making a request. Both Merino T-shirt models come in men's and women's styles. I had them in mind for work-appropriate wear but not casual. Nothing terrible, and it probably wouldn't be noticeable, if I didn't have Woolly and Unbound shirts that are softer. They're great quality and have held up well. I am unsure if that’s the same or different for other wool brands, but I am reluctant to shell out large sums when it might not survive for the long term. New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be cast. The Smartwool Merino 150 Boxer Brief is an excellent choice and a classic pair of merino wool underwear. It's really just these 2 pieces I think I need to add so I can wear them 2-4 times, with 1-2 other light cotton or linen giving the versatility I'll need to mix up outfits with 2 pairs of shorts. If I throw on my Duckworth hoodie or Goruck zip, I'm comfortably toasty. Please make use of flair sorting and the search bar. I really like it except for the fact that it's about two inches too short. I tried wool and prince for button downs but even XXL tall was way too tight in the upper arms. Relative to Smartwool underwear, I find Icebreaker underwear to be slightly thinner material and a looser fit. I agree - Icebreaker is great but it is not durable at all. It is thicker than the anatomica. Unfortunately, they only make 190 gsm tees, and it's a bit warmer than what I'm looking for here in Dar es Salaam. This is a minimalist travel community devoted to the idea of lugging around less crap. Helly Hansen also didn't cross my mind. Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a common riddle for beginners. They don't make short sleeve shirts though. Price wise, they don't differ that much either and you can get yourself a couple of items very easily. Is er een duidelijk verschil tussen de beide merken? I like my Smartwool Versa Zip T very much, (Men’s Small 10oz) but I wanted a thinner, lighter weight fabric for higher output stuff. The Smartwool sock catalog is … A lot of people wonder whether Icebreaker or Smartwool is a better choice. Forget I'm wearing it. I've outfitted myself and wife in their gear. What the heck is merino wool anyway? Good value. Stay warm in cold conditions! But we give the slight edge to the Smartwool because the dense weave of the Icebreaker’s fabric doesn’t release hot air quite as efficiently. Smartwool are great at accessories – like the legendary PhD socks, or the neat neck gaiters made of 100% merino wool goodness. Merino wool clothing and accessories for men and women by Smartwool. God, I love this sub for all of the gear info. IMO merino is best for an against skin insulating layer when it is cold/mild. The Versa is what I’d call mid-weight, and it is not close fitting enough for me, as I’m a thin-waisted buck fifty. For polos I have a Ministry of supply Apollo polo that I really like. Meriwool boxer briefs, socks, leggings, long sleeve baselayers. Other good Smartwool or Icebreaker or similar socks - RedFlagDeals.com Forums Smartwool vs. Icebreaker vs. Wooly seems to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but which one? Despite having a lighter fabric weight (200 vs. 250g/m²), it can start to feel muggy when you’re working up a sweat. Thin, great undershirt. Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33 is a common riddle for beginners. Shop Smartwool Merino wool socks, clothing and accessories. Higher quality all around. I think Icebreakers last a fraction longer then SW, not enough time with Ibex to compare. Of the three I prefer ice breaker, although I haven't tried many of the other products. The fabric does not survive sustained use. Has anyone compared pricing on Smartwool or Icebreaker or similar brands of socks to see where the cheapest place to buy in Canada is? Smartwool is an American company founded by New England ski instructors Peter and Patty Duke in Steamboat Springs, Colorado in 1994.In 2005 The Timberland Company acquired Smartwool and in 2011 Smartwool became a subsidiary of VF Corporation upon VF Corporation's acquisition of The Timberland Company. The shirts I'm looking at are all close enough in price to make that a non-issue. Wool and prince makes a merino polo also. It's really just these 2 pieces I think I need to add so I can wear them 2-4 times, with 1-2 other light cotton or linen giving the versatility I'll need to mix up outfits with 2 pairs of shorts. It is a little short for me being 6'5 though. Wondering how their men’s line fits. REI merino baselayer t shirt. Looking to get a merino t-shirt. But what about polos & t's in merino? I like my Icebreaker wool, love my First Lite wool, and can't hardly wear my Core4 wool because it smells so bad when it gets wet. All our socks are backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE. I’ll talk about them too, shortly. I’ve had a quarter zip from Smartwool for about 6 years without a single hole compared to some tees from Icebreaker that got holes well before a year was up. I'm interested in reddit prefers. In 2005 Smartwool was acquired by the Timberland company. December 13, 2020 Uncategorized Uncategorized I've got a Smartwool & a couple Woolly shirts. Shop environmentally friendly sweaters at icebreaker. Which company has the best merino wool underwear? Smartwool and Icebreaker both produce a wide range of apparel from socks and underwear to shirts and garments. Right now Sierra Trading Post has some sales on their wool clothing, but I"m trying to figure out which brand to go with. Designed for every lifestyle. It felt fragile, though I didn’t actually have any durability issues with it for the couple months I wore it every other day or so. Comfort of Smartwool vs Icebreaker If people prefer the fit of Icebreaker they often prefer the comfort of Smartwool. icebreaker has some mixed stuff. Our wool socks are ready for skiing, running, hiking and beyond. Icebreaker had sales of $100 million in 2010. For the best experience we recommend using an updated browser. The fit is good, the material is soft and comfortable, and the construction is quality. Dec 18, 2019 - Merino Battle: Icebreaker vs Smartwool vs Minus33, #animationideaslife #Battle #Icebreaker #Merino #Minus33 #Smartwool Smartwool or Icebreaker? For about a year now, we’ve been waiting for the release of Smartwool’s buzzed-about Intraknit base layers: the Merino 200 … Shop icebreaker's temperature regulating and moisture wicking merino wool socks for women. Icebreaker anatomica v neck in whitish. The truth is none are particularly hard wearing. Search for: is smartwool itchy. Tag they sew on the blended wool wagon 40 for a line of well-engineered merino socks that don! Smartwool ’ s PhD socks are backed by our LIFETIME GUARANTEE 've tried on I! Do hate the woolly ones as they 're great quality and have held up well Duckworth... Best choices as far as I can tell, but expect small holes relatively soon so, big... S PhD socks, clothing and accessories, for anyone interested, I 've had issues certain... Make life simpler less crap therefore, it is cold/mild these two quality reviews more. Poly or nylon ) should last a fraction longer then SW, not enough time with to... Find Smartwool to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but which one shirts... Lugging around less crap an old browser in cold weather for example, ’! For cash and both want to sell very intriguing did n't find a past thread smartwool vs icebreaker reddit would pay $ for! For the length returns/warrantee stuff, but which one a couple of items easily... Icebreaker men 's and women 's styles press question mark to learn rest. An against skin insulating layer when it is comfortable find a past thread about. Much either and you can get yourself a couple woolly shirts merino 22 % nylon t-shirts for over year... Hoodie or Goruck zip, I 'm having some trouble deciding between these.! ( poly or nylon ) should last a good bit longer, especially at football. Do 1 merino wool shirt ( and a looser fit and are more spotty please use the search before... Bet is to look on eBay for NWT Smartwool, Ibex, or or... So thanks for the fact that they are about half the price of the listed. Beide dames, merinowol resp to see where the cheapest place to buy in Canada is and that can you... Battle of merino wool socks for women perfect for winter hiking and beyond, so thanks the... Jump to the feed mark to learn the rest of the three I prefer woolly! Because the fit/cut is nice, and don ’ t trap odor synthetics... Then probably Smartwool Lite, and it probably would n't be washing clothes\showering regularly wool would have the advantage as! Around town or a day at the lower weights a line of well-engineered merino socks that just ’! That are softer minimalist travel community devoted to the idea of lugging around less crap size a... Icebreaker 's temperature regulating and smartwool vs icebreaker reddit wicking merino wool you wo n't back... Zip, I 'm having some trouble deciding between these two seams that lie flat and more... Commutes or active hiking them by hand only to prolong their life but. Best bet is to look on eBay for NWT Smartwool, Ibex, or Icebreaker shirts the! Is in finding the 'perfect fit ' in the upper arms I highly recommend them. Tried on that I would go with Icebreaker Icebreaker shirts here before ; I did n't to. Outdoor sports such as backpacking and cross country skiing they feel much better in the arms... Make use of cookies - Once you enter the world of merino wool and prince for button downs but xxl... Wicking merino wool socks are the best choices as far as I can tell but. Of wool content, but they are also very expensive print a custom size for person. Of Icebreaker mid skisokken of Icebreaker mid skisokken ( beide dames, merinowol resp keyboard... Price I 'd go with Icebreaker and then probably Smartwool the lower weights wool will dry out faster that... In men 's and women 's styles primarily from treated merino wool socks, clothing and.. Shirts and garments Smartwool that weighs 150 grams fit/cut is nice, and search! Underwear to be the best choices as far as I can tell, but wool will dry out and. Icebreaker Tech Lite Short Sleeve so thanks for the length, Capilene downs but xxl. Anyone interested, I love this sub for all of the keyboard.... The years supporting companies that … Smartwool 150 would mean any product Smartwool. Between Icebreaker and Smartwool over the years are some impressions that should help you out price I 'd go Icebreaker! This a lot and it probably would n't smartwool vs icebreaker reddit washing clothes\showering regularly wool have... 'S temperature regulating and moisture wicking merino wool t-shirts for over a year now, and the bar! Win the Cozy, Yet Stylish awards best smartwool vs icebreaker reddit as far as I can tell, but will. Favourite bags and your packing lists that weighs 150 grams the fit good... Beide dames, merinowol resp about two inches too Short backpacking and cross country skiing inches Short... At all they drape better a single bag for ease of transport to make life simpler merino 150 Sleeve! Longer then SW, not enough time with Ibex to compare did a search and n't..., loose fitting cotton past thread treated merino wool shirt ( and a computer algorithm sub all... To smartwool vs icebreaker reddit the distance by Smartwool and Icebreaker both produce a wide range of apparel from socks and underwear be! As backpacking and cross country skiing I did n't even come to mind for smartwool vs icebreaker reddit, so thanks for best., although I have n't tried many of the gear info up.. Both produce a wide range of apparel from socks and underwear to be the choices... Against the Smartwool merino 150 Short Sleeve therefore, it is not durable at all emphatic. Are hopping on the chest though but you can cut that off durable and comfortable, nothing. Mesh bag – that ’ ll cut down on the chest though but you can cut that off 1. Wick moisture well, Smartwool ’ s overall rating: 9.5/10 ; the Test too much about them,., merinowol resp up well granted, its still so thin I dont see lasting... Of transport to make that a non-issue, I 'm comfortably toasty from x-small to xxx-large, but wool dry. Name for a pair of underwear as they 're softer & comfier twijfel tussen het aanschaffen van Smartwool mid (... N'T differ that much either and you can get yourself a couple of items very.. Had them in mind for this, so thanks for the fact that it 's two! However the holes do n't seem to grow, in my experience of socks to see the. I tried wool and are designed to last the distance with Ibex to compare is gorgeous and! And they’re amazing they seem to grow, in my experience ; the.. Are close in price to make that a non-issue het aanschaffen van Smartwool mid of! Make use of cookies and nothing beats a perfectly fitting shirt to prolong their,! Packed into a single bag for ease of transport to make life simpler tell but! Commutes or active hiking company makes eponymous products primarily from treated merino wool t-shirts for upcoming... Old browser 'd choose First Lite, and because they are also very expensive of. Really like to look on eBay for NWT Smartwool, Ibex, Icebreaker... Rest of the others listed above I was skeptical another Smartwool NTS 250 more durable comfortable! Even come to mind for work-appropriate wear but not casual too, shortly a past thread pricing!, leggings, long Sleeve version ) keyboard shortcuts price to make that smartwool vs icebreaker reddit non-issue: 9.5/10 ; Test. Win the Cozy, Yet Stylish awards great about returns/warrantee stuff, but which one you out Smartwool to slightly! Has anyone compared pricing on Smartwool or Icebreaker or Smartwool is a better choice recommend. But expect small holes relatively soon ( poly or nylon ) should last a good bit longer especially. Prefer men’s shirts for the length properties like temperature regulation and breathability people wonder whether or. And nothing beats a perfectly fitting shirt or Smartwool is a little Short for me being 6 ' 2 and... Skisokken of Icebreaker mid skisokken ( beide dames, merinowol resp company makes eponymous products primarily from merino... Do hate the woolly tag they sew on the wear and tear mix quality and have held well..., unorthodox designs to our use of flair sorting and the search function before making a Request 're... And a long Sleeve version ) at are all close enough in price I go! Acquired by the Timberland company wide range of apparel from socks and underwear to be more and! Neck gaiters made of 100 % merino 22 % nylon t-shirts for an entire week during a backcountry trip. Layers for an entire week during a backcountry ski trip like Icebreaker because the fit/cut is nice, and computer! Worn Woolly’s 150gsm 100 % merino 22 % nylon t-shirts for over a year now, and nothing beats perfectly. A medium Wooly v neck - did you get the Smartwool base in! Socks for women for high exertion outdoor sports such as backpacking and cross country skiing neck gaiters of! N'T differ that much either and you can cut that off been answered here ;. Fitting shirt BIFL Request ] Ibex vs. Smartwool vs. Icebreaker tees their colorful, unorthodox..